Higher education needs a mechanism to challenge student accommodations

I don’t begrudge granting help to students who need it, but we must also have guard rails to deny it to those who don’t, says Nikolay Kukushkin

Published on
February 7, 2025
Last updated
February 7, 2025
A court of appeal nameplate
Source: eurobanks/iStock

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (3)

How do you know which students need accommodations and which don't ? Many students have undeclared disabilities and your blanket ban will compromise their ability to compete on a level playing field.
UK Prof here. Might as well just assume everybody has a “disability” these days. There is no verification, and the staff employed to adjudicate this stuff have realised they can go home earlier and have a quieter life by saying yes to everybody who asks. Result is the diligent and the industrious among students are screwed. And we wonder why the UK is slipping down the toilet!
You need to be more explicit about how the diligent and industrious students are being screwed. In my experience the only accommodations available to disabled students are a) extra time/breaks/separate rooms for exams, b) availability of an extension for assignments (usually 1 week), c) provision for them to contact staff for clarifications, review of assignment plans etc, d) provision of specialist software (e.g. for dyslexia aids), e) easier path to obtaining a resit with no mark cap. These are only granted with medical evidence. For many disabilities, in many parts of the UK the waiting list for diagnosis is as much as 2 years. Of the above the only ones that might be attractive to diligent non-disabled students are extra time. But it is worth pointing out unis can't make time. They are not giving the students more time, they are letting them use more of their own. Meaning they are not using it for casual work, or extra study, or social activities to give them a proper study/life balance. The secret to making a level playing field is for professors to change their practice so it is inclusive to all, and so any accommodations needed are minimal, or non-existent.

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT