Harassment and discrimination are still rife within universities

A recent survey confirms that higher education continues to offer a safe environment for a certain kind of abuser: the successful professor who brings in large grants, say Nanna Haug Hilton and Susanne Täuber

Published on
January 20, 2022
Last updated
January 20, 2022
Male professor rescued with women and people of colour left to drown
Source: Stephen Schildbach/Getty

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline: A sanctuary for abuse?

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Reader's comments (4)

This story is yet another aspect of the dire relations ow running between administration and staff. Administrations are now injurious and parasitic. The situation will continue until staff and students unite in an attempt to effectively attack administration culture which quite obviously does not give a damn for university people, or indeed much for the courses they offer. They might as well be selling flavored yoghurts. The whole thing has become a commercialized enterprise involved in making money by full time employees intent on screwing the staff to the maximum extent on low pay and ephemeral contracts. Anyone who steps out of line can be easily emarginated. It is a highly efficient and sophisticated form of corruption comparable to near-Eastern political states run by oligarchies indifferent to the wellbeing of its citizens. I am sorry, but I think revolutionary tactics are the only thing left to us. We need to wait until everyone has been informed of what is going on. They need to be kicked out by force. Violence is not out of the question. Steel yourselves, find your courage, publicize what is going on, and unite. Contact me on Twitter https://twitter.com/eumenades. See also Chomsky's revealing article: https://www.jacobinmag.com/2014/03/the-death-of-american-universities/
The problems are real, but the report that is quoted is a bad piece of work that does a disservice to the issue. The respondents were self selected, and in no way representative of the university population. The problem is by no means restricted to male Dutch professors - there are more than enough painful examples of female or international professors who behave just as badly. The underlying cause is the increasingly hierarchical organization of Dutch universities, where academic staff are little more than ordinary employees, and where full professors (male or female) can rule their fiefdoms, given the formal regulations. Smart ones don't, but precisely academically weak ones often do, to make up for their lack of authority. The problem with the Dutch system is that it is modelled on the traditional German one, but unlike in Germany gives these professors large numbers of permanent staff who are in many respects their equals (or even academically much better), but not in power. Similarly, with PhD students, most of them are actually not students but temporary employees under the power and authority of full professsors who traditionally are the only ones allowed to supervise PhD students. Hence PhDs cannot easily escape, but are tied to their supervisor. So yes, I am sure there are some academically very successful male professors who bring in large grants and feel that this entitles them to all kinds of bad behaviour (there are indeed documented cases), but that is only the tip of the iceberg. All this is aggravated by a research funding system targeted at large projects under a principal investigator rather than individual scholars. The competition for that kind of funding often involves quite a bit of politics rather than merit.
Hi there. Yes I can see your problems. And I appreciate your concern concerning the precarity of Phd students. You say, "involves quite a bit of politics rather than merit". To me, as you might guess, the whole thing is determined by politics and relations of power. Not only that but the situation is now international. Administrations are expanding themselves and creating more and more economic class divisions. This means class-conflict from the traditional Marxist viewpoint. (I am not a Marxist.) The whole thing can look a lot simpler by asking, Who gets the money? We are now in a position where universities are being run solely for the purposes of profit on the corporate business model. This is very bad for anybody who cares about knowledge and education. An analysis of the progress of liberal capitalism in our time will be very enlightening - the whole thing is going on, everywhere. If we do not inform ourselves properly about what is happening, and do not form groups for organized opposition, we are ****ed. It is as simple as that. But one can also see that the police are getting more and more sophisticated in their suppression of protest and effective opposition. This whole thing needs thinking over.
And planning! https://twitter.com/eumenades

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT