Paper rejected after plagiarism detector stumped by references

Editors say episode demonstrates need for humans to review work of software

Published on
June 26, 2019
Last updated
June 26, 2019
Dalek
Source: Alamy

POSTSCRIPT:

Print headline: Confused robot says no to paper

Register to continue

Why register?

  • Registration is free and only takes a moment
  • Once registered, you can read 3 articles a month
  • Sign up for our newsletter
Please
or
to read this article.

Related articles

Peer review is lauded in principle as the guarantor of quality in academic publishing and grant distribution. But its practice is often loathed by those on the receiving end. Here, seven academics offer their tips on good refereeing, and reflect on how it may change in the years to come

6 December

Reader's comments (2)

...and you think this is exclusive to academe? The big consultancy firms have been selling this idea to large corporations for years. Mostly used in purchasing the accountants like it because it removes any professional judgement, skill and expensive people. Because they control the data, they can prove how much they appear to have saved. Beware - nobody noticed in the commercial world - robots have no sense of value.
It also gets in the way of integrating assessment across a course. Say you have a final year project module and one about testing running concurrently. So the lecturer writing the testing module invites students to use their project in their testing coursework, empowering them to apply their new-learned testing skills to a real piece of work. Great you might think... until they write their project reports and naturally wish to explain how they tested their work. All Turnitin's bells go off at once! Of course this is an opportunity to teach the students about 'self-plagiarism' and the need to reference things that they themselves have written elsewhere - but it's just as well this was spotted in time to give them the necessary guidance BEFORE they handed in their reports :)

Sponsored

Featured jobs

See all jobs
ADVERTISEMENT